For over a decade, while Buffalo’s working class saw property taxes climb and infrastructure crumble, one of the city’s crown jewels Marina was being operated for the price of a pack of gum.
New investigations into the city’s handling of its waterfront reveal a startling pattern of what critics call institutionalized cronyism. After a decade-long sweetheart deal with Smith Boys, the City of Buffalo has decided to moved on.
Yet, the new solution looks suspiciously like the old problem.
The Decade of the Dollar Deal
The audit trail is a roadmap of fiscal negligence. From 2014 to late 2024, Smith Boys operated the Erie Basin Marina under a contract so lopsided it bordered on the absurd. While the marina generated an estimated $900,000 annually in fuel sales, slip fees, and services, the City of Buffalo collected just $1 per year in base rent.
When the Comptroller’s office finally rang the alarm in 2025, the fallout was swift. The city terminated the Smith Boys’ lease, promising a transparent, competitive process to find a professional, high-yield partner for the 2026 season.
The Revolving Door of Management
In February 2026, the Buffalo Common Council announced its winner: Marina Management Group, LLC. On the surface, it appeared to be a fresh start. A deeper dive into the LLC’s filing, however, reveals a familiar web of connections.
The new group is spearheaded by Jay Davidson, a well-connected restaurateur behind Liberty Hound, The Terrace, and most notably a former long-time employee of Smith Boys.
The optics are devastating. The city ousted an operator for gross financial mismanagement, only to hand the keys back to a group led by an insider from that very same operation. It raises a haunting question for Buffalo taxpayers: Did the management actually change, or did they just change the letterhead?
A Cloak of Secrecy
The process of awarding this new contract has been anything but transparent. The City Comptroller’s office has publicly slammed the Common Council for rushing the Request for Qualifications (RFQ) process behind closed doors during the winter months of late 2025.
“The city has known about the rot at Erie Basin Marina for years,” a memo from the Comptroller’s office stated in early 2026. To exclude the primary financial watchdog from the selection of a new operator is not just a procedural error, it is a red flag for the entire city.
Common Council members have defended the speed of the deal, citing the urgent need to have the marina operational for the 2026 boating season. But for many, the urgency feels like a convenient excuse to bypass the rigorous vetting. The vetting process is especially important given the previous operator had the contract for ten years and might have grossed 7 figures.
The Bottom Line
Buffalo’s waterfront is more than just a place to park boats; it is a vital economic engine. For ten years, that engine was allowed to run for the benefit of a private entity at the expense of the public.
As the 2026 season approaches, the slips at Erie Basin will be full, and the fuel will be pumping. But until the city can prove that this “new” deal isn’t just another handshake between friends, the stench of the old contract will continue to hang over the harbor.
About Lake Erie Times: Lake Erie Times is your comprehensive source for the latest news, insights, and stories from Buffalo, New York, and the broader Western New York region. Our mission is to provide the community with accurate, in-depth, and engaging news coverage, fostering informed dialogue and strengthening connections within our region.
Disclaimer: The content provided by Lake Erie Times is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as professional legal or financial advice.
Affiliate Disclaimer: Some links on Lake Erie Times are affiliate links. This means that if you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Our recommendations are based on careful research and our commitment to quality journalism.
