In a case that has gripped Western New York for years, convicted serial killer Richard Fox has been sentenced to an additional 25 years to life in prison for the murder of Crystal Curthoys. This latest ruling brings his total sentence to 65 years to life, effectively ensuring the 67-year-old remains behind bars for the remainder of his life. The sentencing marks a somber milestone for a community long haunted by a string of disappearances and grisly discoveries across Buffalo and Niagara Falls.
Justice for Crystal Curthoys
Earlier this year, Fox admitted to the 2023 killing of 32-year-old Crystal Curthoys. Investigators revealed that Fox exploited his position as a handyman to gain access to Curthoys’ residence. While the crime occurred in 2023, the full extent of the tragedy was only realized when her remains were discovered hidden beneath the basement stairs of Fox’s former residence in Niagara Falls. During the proceedings, the court noted the calculated nature of the crime, with the presiding judge describing Fox’s history as one of “profound evil.”
The Timeline of a Serial Killer
The conviction for Curthoys’ murder is the latest in a series of admissions that have linked Fox to decades of violence in the region. Fox was already serving life sentences for the murders of Cassandra Watson and Marquita Mull, whose cases were solved through a combination of forensic breakthroughs and investigative persistence by local authorities.
| Victim | Year of Death | Location of Crime | Discovery Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beatrice Meabon | 1976 | Brant, NY | Died in hospital; Fox confessed in 2024. |
| Cassandra Watson | 2003-2004 | Buffalo, NY | Remains found in 2021 in Chautauqua County. |
| Marquita Mull | 2021 | Buffalo, NY | Body recovered in 2021 in Portland, NY. |
| Crystal Curthoys | 2023 | Niagara Falls, NY | Found in Fox’s basement in 2023. |
Uncovering the Past: Watson and Mull
The investigation into Fox’s crimes deepened significantly in 2021. Skeletal remains found by a hiker along the Chautauqua Rails to Trails near Woleben Road in Portland were eventually identified as Cassandra Watson. Forensic analysis determined that Watson, who was killed in the City of Buffalo between 2003 and 2004, had been buried for nearly two decades. Her identity remained a mystery until 2024, when investigators established a link between her disappearance and Fox.
While processing the scene for Watson’s remains, investigators discovered the body of 50-year-old Marquita Mull. Mull had been reported missing by her family in June 2021. Fox later confessed to killing her in Buffalo and transporting her remains to the same hiking trail area in Chautauqua County, establishing a chilling pattern of disposal.
A 50-Year History of Violence
Beyond the legal convictions, a startling admission by Fox shed light on a cold case dating back nearly 50 years. Fox confessed to the 1976 murder of his own grandmother, Beatrice Meabon. Meabon was found stabbed in her Cain Road home in the Town of Brant and later died from her injuries. Because Fox was a juvenile at the time of the stabbing, he cannot be legally prosecuted for the crime. However, the admission provides long-awaited answers for a family that has endured decades of uncertainty.
The resolution of these cases brings a painful chapter to a close for Western New York. While the “profound evil” described by the court cannot be undone, the 65-year total sentence ensures that Fox will no longer pose a threat to the community he preyed upon for half a century.
For more updates on local justice and community safety, stay connected with Lake Erie Times.
